Skip to main content
Pop Culture

Nick Carter Calls Accuser's Sealing Bid 'Hypocrisy'

Ava Hart
Ava HartAuthor
Published
Reading time1 min
Share:
Nick Carter Calls Accuser's Sealing Bid 'Hypocrisy'

Nick Carter is pushing back against an effort by Melissa Schuman to seal the transcript of her April 2026 deposition, according to court documents obtained by TMZ. The Backstreet Boys singer characterized the request as the "total embodiment of hypocrisy and regret," TMZ reported on Friday, November 20, 2026.

In the filings, Carter argues that Schuman's legal maneuvering is inconsistent with the public nature of her accusations. He contends that Schuman "unilaterally and strategically decided to launch a highly publicized defamatory campaign against" him "rather than exercising discretion with her false tale and initiating the instant action anonymously," according to the documents obtained by TMZ.

Carter further asserts that in the years preceding the lawsuit, Schuman attempted to interfere with his business dealings and spread what he describes as false statements about him in a documentary and in television interviews. He maintains that Schuman seeks to keep the deposition transcript sealed because, in his view, it would expose her claims as a "clear fabrication."

The filing includes a sharply worded critique of Schuman's position: "Out of one side of her mouth, [Melissa] publicly defames and vilifies [Nick] with horrendous lies and, out of the other side, asks this court to shield her ongoing fraud and perjury from being exposed," Carter states in the documents obtained by TMZ.

As TMZ previously reported, Schuman sued Carter over an alleged assault at his Los Angeles apartment in 2003. Carter has adamantly denied the claims. He also alleges that Schuman conspired with another woman, Shannon Ruth, who has likewise accused him of sexual assault, in an attempt to shake him down with false accusations. Both cases remain ongoing.

The dispute over the deposition transcript underscores the broader tension in the litigation over how much of the pretrial record should remain public. Carter's argument centers on the contrast between Schuman's public accusations and her request for confidentiality at the deposition stage, a position his legal team frames as inconsistent. The court has not yet ruled on the sealing request, and the underlying cases continue to proceed.

Ava Hart

About the Author

Ava Hart

Ava Hart is a pop culture junkie and loves to share what's happening in Hollywood and what trends are taking the world by storm.

Share:

Related Stories

USDA Hack Raises Food Safety Concerns
Pop Culture

USDA Hack Raises Food Safety Concerns

A cyberattack on the U.S. Department of Agriculture's farmer payment system has prompted worries that hackers could reach sensitive food safety data. Two former USDA officials told NBC News about the breach, which comes amid a wave of outages and attacks across federal agencies and private companies.

11/21/2026
Ava Hart
Bowen Yang Apologizes, Nick Cannon Seeks Prayers
Pop Culture

Bowen Yang Apologizes, Nick Cannon Seeks Prayers

Bowen Yang issued a public apology on November 20 for an antisemitic slur used on his podcast, while Nick Cannon asked fans for prayers from a hospital bed amid his lupus battle and Leighton Meester opened up about her marriage to Adam Brody.

11/21/2026
Ava Hart
Columbus Left in Dark on New 'Home Alone' Sequel
Pop Culture

Columbus Left in Dark on New 'Home Alone' Sequel

Christopher Columbus, director of the first two 'Home Alone' films, reportedly was not informed that Macaulay Culkin is developing a new installment with Disney and producer Seth Rogen. Columbus also warned that the project may struggle without Catherine O'Hara.

11/21/2026
Ava Hart
WOND - banner