A Vincent van Gogh canvas rich in blues, yellows and greens is expected to draw as much as $180 million when it goes under the hammer at Sotheby's in New York on Wednesday evening, a figure that could establish a new benchmark for the Dutch artist. The work, however, arrives at auction carrying a provenance dispute rooted in Nazi persecution during the 1930s.
The painting, Châtaigniers en Fleurs — Blossoming Chestnut Trees in English — dates to 1890. It was formerly the property of Samuel and Hedwig Fischer, a German Jewish couple. Samuel Fischer established a publishing house whose roster of authors included Thomas Mann and Hermann Hesse.
Nazi persecution disrupted the Fischer publishing business, and in 1936 the family parted with the canvas by way of an Amsterdam gallery. The sale is proceeding only after the present owners and the Fischers' descendants reached a last-minute agreement. The descendants maintain that the painting changed hands under financial pressure created by Nazi persecution.
Christopher A. Marinello, an attorney who specializes in recovering lost and stolen art and who founded Art Recovery International, told Morning Edition that claims of this kind present evidentiary hurdles that differ from cases in which the Nazis physically seized artworks.
"They're a little bit harder to prove, but they certainly carry the same amount of weight," Marinello told NPR Topics: National.
Marinello portrayed a market that has been slow to reckon with its own history. He recalled one client who, after World War II, had to journey to Switzerland in order to repurchase a work that had been his own. He also recounted meetings with dealers who had assumed the original owners were no longer alive.
"Oh, we thought you were dead," Marinello told NPR Topics: National, describing what dealers said to him.
"They wanted the Holocaust cases to go away," Marinello told NPR Topics: National.
Sotheby's declined to disclose the agreement's terms. In conversation with NPR's A Martínez, Marinello examined forced sales from the Nazi period, the obstacles that restitution efforts continue to face, and the reasons the art trade remains engaged with Holocaust-era losses roughly eight decades after the war ended.










